In-House Marketing Team vs Outsourcing: What’s Best for Recruitment Marketing?

In recruitment, marketing isn’t just a nice thing to have, it’s one of the most vital functions for growth...  

But when it comes to how you deliver marketing, many businesses face a dilemma… build an in-house marketing team or outsource to a specialist recruitment marketing agency?

At Gatt Consulting, we’ve worked with recruitment agencies that have tried both paths. And while there are pros to each, the case for outsourcing your marketing becomes clearer when you want impact without overextending resources.

Here’s a breakdown of both sides and why outsourcing marketing often wins for recruitment businesses...

Advantages of an In-House Marketing Team

• Deep internal alignment - Your marketing team works daily with your sales team and your leadership team. They know your unique processes, culture and recruitment challenges inside out.

• Faster internal feedback loops - Changes, tweaks, ideas. Things move faster because everyone sits in the same office (or virtually integrated).

Challenges & Hidden Costs of an In-House Marketing Team 

• Recruitment and overheads - Salaries, benefits, training, tools, software subscriptions, the costs quickly add up. 

• Skill gaps and constant up-skilling - Marketing tools and SEO best practices change rapidly. Recruiting people who are expert at everything (SEO, automation, social) is rare, which usually means ongoing training is required or if not provided, a skills gap is opened up. 

• Capacity limitations - Juggling website updates, blogs, SEO, nurture sequences, content creation, social posts, email marketing campaigns and reporting, often means marketing teams become over stretched or worst case key activities are not executed.

• Risk of tunnel vision - Internal teams can sometimes lack exposure to broader best practices. They often fall into habits and don’t look at the bigger picture… how is it impacting lead generation, growth and ROI.

• Lack of strategic thinking - It is often thought by business leaders that every marketing professional can develop and execute a marketing strategy, this just isn't the case. That lack of strategic thinking is often the reason why your marketing function doesn't deliver the growth and opportunity it should for your business.

Why Outsourcing to a Specialist Recruitment Marketing Agency Often Makes More Sense

If your goal is to scale and get measurable results without overstretching your budget or team, outsourcing your marketing becomes a strong option. Here’s how:

Key Advantages of Outsourcing Marketing... 

• Access to expert marketing skills and tools - We live and breathe recruitment marketing. We’ve invested in tools, built playbooks and worked across many niches, meaning you benefit from best-in-class capability right away. You won’t need to hire, train and wait for your internal resource to get to grips with the recruitment industry. 

• Lower fixed costs, more flexibility - You don’t need to hire multiple roles internally. You pay for what you need, when you need it. Strategy, SEO, mentorship, email marketing and automations, social campaigns. This approach reduces risk and overheads.

• Faster impact - Since specialist recruitment marketing agencies have pre-built processes, templates and experience, they can get campaigns live, content published and improvements made much quicker than an in-house marketing team building everything from scratch.

• Scalable outcomes - As your recruitment agency grows, outsourcing your marketing allows you to scale marketing up (or down) without needing to hire more headcount, avoiding delays or growing pains.

• Accountability and results focus - Specialist recruitment marketing agencies measure success, not just activity. At Gatt Consulting, we ensure every marketing campaign has clear objectives and regular reviews. You see where leads come from, which content converts and what ROI looks like.

When In-House Marketing and Outsourcing Hybrid Works Best

It’s not always one or the other. Some recruitment agencies find the best approach to marketing is a mix of in-house and outsourcing:

• Keep one or two marketing professionals (depending on the size of your business) in-house for internal alignment, culture and brand control.

• Use outsourcing to fill in specialist gaps, such as SEO, content production, automation and advanced analytics.

• Outsource for peaks/campaigns while maintaining a lean internal core.

My Summary on In-House Marketing Team vs Outsourcing: What’s Best for Recruitment Marketing?

If I were advising a recruitment agency on where to invest, especially early on or when cash is tightly allocated, I’d lean heavily toward outsourcing. It gives you capability, speed, flexibility and scale, with less risk and fewer fixed costs.

How We Bridge the Marketing Gap 

At Gatt, we combine the benefits of a boutique agency (personal, aligned, responsive) with the skillset of a full specialist marketing function. Here’s how we do it:

• We start with a discovery session, so we understand your current marketing strengths, weaknesses and opportunities.

• Then we develop a strategy customised to your agency, which may mean SEO foundational work, quick wins with email automation, content planning and social media optimisation.

• We mentor your internal team (if you have one), so they learn new skills and don’t feel left behind.

• We deliver regular reports, so you can see what’s working and adjust accordingly.

Want Support With Marketing Your Recruitment Agency?

If you are interested in finding out more how we can help your business, get in touch and we can arrange a time that suits you to discuss how marketing can become the growth engine that you want for your business.

Contact Us